Carlito
Player Valuation: £40m
There are better players at worse teams than Everton.And they've walked through us far easier when those two haven't played (Barnsley, first half at Reading, Bournemouth after McCarthy went off - to name a few examples).
Most of the goals we concede (in fact, the vast majority) are from crosses into the box, that the goalkeeper and defenders fail to deal with.
McCarthy and Barry constantly get stick from a certain section of the fanbase. And that's just down to opinion. But they're quite clearly our best two options there, and I'm pretty sure that any other team in the league barring the teams above us would happily have quality like that in their midfield.
It wouldn't be so bad if there was a little bit of rotation for games where they're likely to get overran, such as next week against Palace, but there's more chance of Howard sitting out than either of those two.