It being pretty wank seems to be the commonly held view all over the internet’s from what I’ve seen. Then again that could just be LOTR nerds dominating the conversation.
Ive not seen it myself
Its not ground breaking, or hyper-emotionally investing. Its not revolutionary in graphic storytelling, visceral or intellectually psycological. It doesn’t reinvent the wheel, or burn down the house it was born in.
Its a simple tale, told with all the tools from the Peter Jackson toolbelt, cgi and special effects out the yin yang, costumes for days, sets for miles, wooden dialogue believing every word it utters and scores soaring when epic and fluting softly when close and personal.
People seem to have become the arbiters of the Tolkein Universe and have forgotten the stereotypical warblings of victorian era fantasist hold no basis in reality and can interpreted any which but loose, apparently.
Its Friday night fare, washes over you like an expensive Le’ Petit Marseilles and then is rinsed away and down the drain and you move onto the next thing. Its popcorn telly and to let it get stuck in your throat is about as useful to you as Eshers stairs.
Its not Breaking Bad, Game of Thrones or Chernobyl, and you have to just enjoy Middle Earth for what it is. Completely made up.