who's our best goalkeeper

Jo3Fr3sh · October 19, 2015

Cheese on toast

Joey66 · October 19, 2015

Can we close this as Robles is winning!

Kieno said:
We need a new 'keeper. Howard is a liability - but Robles is 10 times the liability. Anyone who thinks otherwise is off their head!

Robles wouldn't even get the shout for the Capital Cup game against Norwich if I had my way. He's gonna cost us in that competition....mark my words!

Kept three clean sheets last year in the premier first game A Derby at home oh a clean sheet as he came for the ball!

tommye · October 19, 2015

USABlue · October 19, 2015

should make results public and not let people change votes btw. should be for all polls tbh

Kiwi · October 19, 2015

Neville Southall.

Haven't voted because the use of best in the poll is a fallacy. More like "least bad".

Zatara · October 19, 2015

Should have an option, both rubbish cant compare. Would have 90% of the votes.

Michaelcoyb · October 19, 2015

Only 70 odd votes @Dithering Dougie , but the thread has 130 odd posts!

How can you ensure everyone has voted? :bye:

Rook · October 19, 2015

Unafraid to leave the line. Absoultely refuses to let ball past him.

http://i.imgur.com/bb01r1F.gifv

JAYTALITY · October 19, 2015

Is this why the crap Howard thread was locked?

JAYTALITY · October 19, 2015

Eggs said:
...Howard is our best keeper because the Manager picks him ahead of Robles. If Robles was the better he would play. Goalkeeper has never been a transfer priority but it's definitely creeping up the list, there's a keeper at Southend who I reckon is worth keeping an eye on.

It's been number one on my list for years.

royvernon39 · October 19, 2015

Robles.

He was class when he had a chance to shine last season.

Gwladys St. Glory · October 19, 2015

Feck it, bring Russell Griffiths back from loan...we'll win it with the kids.

JAYTALITY · October 19, 2015

Prevenger17 said:
Echoes of lads clamouring for Garbutt to replace Baines last season. Joel isn't the solution. I would have given him a run last season when we were safe and had nothing to lose but that time is over now. Howard has been good this season, our second walloping hasn't changed that.

He's been Ok but I really do think we need and are able to get a better keeper and should have done it a long time ago.

ilikecheese · October 19, 2015

For those clamoring for a better option in January, do you really think we have the funds to improve this position?

Begovic was 8 mil in the summer.

I think we all agree that we need to improve this position, but at what cost? The shouts for Butland are out of our price range IMO...thinking in the 15 mil range for him. If Joel is your answer, then sadly IMO you are not looking to improve the position, you are just going for an anybody but Howard argument which is silly. Howard is better than Joel. If Joel was better than Howard the manager that bought him would have given him his chance.

Eggs · October 19, 2015

Jaytality said:
It's been number one on my list for years.

...that's a matter of opinion. In retrospect I think Howard has been a good signing but I agree that standards have slipped in the last 18 months or so. For me, bringing in the likes of Lukaku was more of a priority than replacing an adequate (at the time) Howard.