Not defending him as such. A lot of things I didn't like about Carlo, especially his reluctance to give youth players any kind of chance.
Just playing devils advocate really. There's no doubt he had a positive effect on the likes of DCL and Keane especially, the latter being an absolute wreck under Silva, but also Davies put on half a dozen of his best performances in an Everton shirt. Think he managed the Pickford issue very well too.
But the likes of Kean, Iwobi, Gomes and especially Richarlison regressed under him.