Think people are getting a bit too distracted by irrelevancies.
It’s just about a game of football. That involves picking eleven players that you think suit a game plan, motivating them to run and tackle and do the things that the game plan requires.
And quite simply: the personnel he picked did not suit the plan, the plan didn't suit the game, and the players didn't look motivated or hungry.
That doesn’t mean Carlo out or whatever. He needs time to understand the squad, alter it, find a system that works etc. But today was a huge failure on basic requirements.
We were awful today, but we could/should have been 3 or 4 up at HT.
If we’d finished our dinner in the first half, we wouldn’t be having that discussion.
The second half might well have been the worst 45mins of football I’ve ever seen from an Everton side, but I sincerely doubt Ancelotti’s half time instructions were: “right lads, I want you to go out and not only fail to show an ounce of fight or energy, I also want you (including the 8 or 9 of you who are full international level players) to completely forget how to complete 5 yard passes or even to pass the ball forwards”
Today (and particularly the 2nd 45) was an utter failure of the playing staff.
Are there some extenuating factors? Sure, to an extent - the majority of them were clearly out on their feet - a result of going into and through the hectic Christmas schedule with a massively depleted squad, and those who remained having to play too much football in too short a time... but there was no excuse for the complete lack of effort, particularly from those two who started in central midfield.
Sigurdsson was woeful in that second half - in the first he still least put in a few balls and was involved in 2 or 3 of the chances we should have buried, but in the second half, he genuinely might as well not have been there.
And Schneiderlin.... Morgan Schneiderlin. There aren’t words strong enough to express my utter disdain for that man, that wouldn’t get me booted from this site.
The sight of him strolling around the pitch, putting in not even 1% effort, even after we were losing 1-0 to a bunch of kids... If I never see him in an Everton shirt again it will be far too soon. An utter disgrace to the badge and not worthy of being allowed to call himself an Everton player for a moment longer.