catcherintherye
Player Valuation: £80m
What we can agree on is this.
We have spend money badly. But if its 60m, (and I know wages come into things) but on fees we could get Gray, Broja and Dennis for a similar ish price.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
- Status
What we can agree on is this.
We have spend money badly. But if its 60m, (and I know wages come into things) but on fees we could get Gray, Broja and Dennis for a similar ish price.
catcherintherye
Player Valuation: £80m
Apparently they arent put off. They offered 30m for Wood. I live in hope.
I think we will get relegated if we sell
catcherintherye
Player Valuation: £80m
Footballs about opinions really. I havent seen it with Jesus yet. Not convinced at all.
Theres also a case, given that Nunez has played outside a top 5 league, and Vlahovic has only done it in Serie A (and honestly has a similar record at Juventus to Kean) he is a better option as things stand.
Before his injury DCL had 13 and 16 goals in the previous 2 seasons. To me that carries as much weight as 7 & 17 in Serie A or 26 & 6 in Portugal.
Those lads have gone for 73m and 75m respectively. I can see why DCL might be an option for teams at 60m, IF you feel hes over his injuries.
catcherintherye
Player Valuation: £80m
What if we got Broja in.
4737carlin
Player Valuation: £90m
Yeah but when did they buy Wood, January as an overpayment to stay up,not a chance they pay much for DCL, our situation goes against us too much
catcherintherye
Player Valuation: £80m
Well its shown they are willing to pay for players to come.
Our situation, re FFP is now resolved, for 12 months at least. We are negotiating in a much better position.
If anything our position is also desperate, as he would be key to stay up.
CielosGrises
Player Valuation: £20m
Losing both Richy and DCL would be a big gamble - effectively our only real matchwinners in a borderline relegation side.
luuk_deventer
Player Valuation: £8m
I agree he should and would obviously be more than Wood. But he is not an elite striker. His value is driven by his performances 2 years ago and will be affected by his big injury last year.
£30-£40m and teams would be interested. Any more than that and there is better value out there.
Richarlison was sold for £50m, which is around the figure I said when the rumours first started. Richarlison is better than Dom and there is no world where Dom goes for more.
kiss the crest
Player Valuation: £35m
This.
Even if we dont sell, we have to improve that squad because there are no goals in that team, anyone who doesn't score goes down
Without question mate. Always liked Jesus, think City was a poor move for him overall, he’s better than he got and was used there, I’m really tipping him next year, we‘l see. Mad that it seems City need to raise these fund to accommodate Halland.
He’s worth about 70 mill to us. But not sure he’s a 70 mill pound player, he’s a good player, but not at that elite striking level or a killer like say a Vardy, or a Kane, one chance and it’s goodnight, certainly in two. Dom misses to much with ball at feet, unless it’s coming across in the box.
Personaly I’d keep him, because it’s the hardest thing in the league to get a striker capable of double digits and we have priorities elsewhere and seems unnecessarily risky after Richarlison. But I’d be open minded next summer. He’s good at dimensions, but limited at others, but he offers a good bit, just not at that elite level. If we were 5/6th he’s at that level.
Part of me is tempted, because the only manager to get a tune out of him was Carlo, Silva got some performances out of him but not consistently goals. So if he struggles next season under Frank I’d be very interested in cashing our chips, I actually think it could be a big season ahead of him career wise.
Last edited:
catcherintherye
Player Valuation: £80m
On Richarlison, there are a range of fees, with 50m being the very lowest end. Sure someone said 55m down recently. The range seems to be between 50-70m. That was above what you seemed to be saying.
On the 2nd point, I'm not entirely sure that's true. His record isnt as good over the last few years. They are different players. For Newcastle and what they want, Dom would be the better fit IMO.
I probably peg his value similar to you. Probably more 35-40 ish. But there are multiple factors that dictate a sale, including value to a buyer, and need to a seller. Teams will often overpay.
I agree he has lost a lot of value last year because of injuries. Last year there was talk of a 75m ish from Arsenal. The question is, how much has his value been hit with injury.
I agree hes not elite, but nobody elite or close to is going to Newcastle. He knows the league, fits their style and is a younger, better upgrade on what they have, who would go. They will try and hard ball, but honestly, when you have that cash, you probably face pressure to spend it. I think it would be an error to pay 60m from them, but it's the sort of error sides plush with cash, but no history tend to make. City did similar with Lescott.
As a final aside, we dont need to sell, so are obviously not going to entertain at value bids of say 35-40m. There would have to be an overpay to get us interested. The question is how much premium could we effectively get away with.
4737carlin
Player Valuation: £90m
What if he gets injured? If we are pinning all our hopes on this one player we have problems
- Status