Transfer Rumour Dwight McNeil

[Nymzee]

He can play left, right and centre. Belting cross on him. Would work well for Dom but then it moves Richy elsewhere (not that I'm arsed since he's been poor for ages).

However at £30m+ I'd rather sign a class RW instead.

 

[windymiller]

He can play left, right and centre. Belting cross on him. Would work well for Dom but then it moves Richy elsewhere (not that I'm arsed since he's been poor for ages).

However at £30m+ I'd rather sign a class RW instead.

Pretty much how I feel about him, a good player to have but not a transformative signing. In any case, I doubt we can get him for £25M and I doubt we have £25M even if we could.

 

[TheBigIguana]

He can play left, right and centre. Belting cross on him. Would work well for Dom but then it moves Richy elsewhere (not that I'm arsed since he's been poor for ages).

However at £30m+ I'd rather sign a class RW instead.

In theory maybe. In practice he's only played on the left.

I'd actually be more into this signing if the idea was to try and move him but that's one of those things you've got to have a well thought out plan for.

 

[Nymzee]

In theory maybe. In practice he's only played on the left.

I'd actually be more into this signing if the idea was to try and move him but that's one of those things you've got to have a well thought out plan for.

Not for England he hasn't.

 

[TheBigIguana]

Not for England he hasn't.

You'll have watched more than me but I did watch two of the u21 games in that weird group stage and he was on the left. In fact in one of them he played LWB.

 

[Nymzee]

You'll have watched more than me but I did watch two of the u21 games in that weird group stage and he was on the left. In fact in one of them he played LWB.

Yeh I've seen him in a few positions. Even play CM once.

 

[Hogwild]

Bad news gang (depending on your thoughts here I suppose). I’m really warming to the idea of McNeil, so that is probably any chance of us getting this over the line scuppered

 

[TheBigIguana]

Yeh I've seen him in a few positions. Even play CM once.

Still he's got 80 some PL appearances and I think a good 70 are on the left. His skillet may allow him to move but I wouldn't be going crazy to spend a lot in that situation.

He's just not my style of player I guess.

 

[Glasshalffull]

In theory maybe. In practice he's only played on the left.

I'd actually be more into this signing if the idea was to try and move him but that's one of those things you've got to have a well thought out plan for.

Shirley you don't suggest that this club would ever do anything without a well thought out plan??? Heaven forefend!

 

[Nymzee]

Still he's got 80 some PL appearances and I think a good 70 are on the left. His skillet may allow him to move but I wouldn't be going crazy to spend a lot in that situation.

He's just not my style of player I guess.

Well I didn't say sign him to play anything but LM just that he has and can play across the pitch. He's a classic winger; not for everyone but I like them.

 

[ilikecheese]

Shirley you don't suggest that this club would ever do anything without a well thought out plan??? Heaven forefend!

 

[jazzy]

Still he's got 80 some PL appearances and I think a good 70 are on the left. His skillet may allow him to move but I wouldn't be going crazy to spend a lot in that situation.

He's just not my style of player I guess.

Have you ever heard of Kevin Sheedy one of our greatest ever left midfielders?

Sounds like you wouldn't have rated him either.

 

[TheBigIguana]

Have you ever heard of Kevin Sheedy one of our greatest ever left midfielders?

Sounds like you wouldn't have rated him either.

Have you looked at a calendar in the last 30 years?

There's a reason they're called "classic" wingers now when they stay really wide and cross.

 

[hktoffee]

Have you ever heard of Kevin Sheedy one of our greatest ever left midfielders?

Sounds like you wouldn't have rated him either.

Need pacy winger just get Bailey with the money not McNeil.

 

[ExpatinBangkok]

He's pretty slow for a winger, so I don't think this is a good buy.. unless he can also play center mid, then maybe...