- Status
4737carlin
Player Valuation: £90m
I no the way the defense went to sleep and let Ali in was poor, your right thou this is the Joel thread, I'll have to look for your comments on the Morgan, Gana, Barry, Williams and Koeman threads who were all also badly at fault today
orly
Please check with me for Blammo criteria
Don't forget Funes the Flop who will be rightly getting stick
royvernon39
Player Valuation: £10m
Three decent stops against one on ones but will be remembered for a shocker with the second goal.
It was so Tim Howard-like.
It was so Tim Howard-like.
loooweee
Player Valuation: £10m
He stopped four goals today and the shot he blocked coming off his line shortly after Kames first goal certainly shows mental strength
Gifted kane 2 goals. One through an error the other through idiocy.
Made some top saves today, but his kicking was wretched as per. Hopefully today puts that particular debate to rest
Still, I'm not blaming him for that today. It would have been double figures without him
Still, I'm not blaming him for that today. It would have been double figures without him
4737carlin
Player Valuation: £90m
Second yes was crazy, first was poor but no more at fault then either Gana or Barry who let him get the shot off, as good as Joel is at keeping clean sheets he is never going to do it everyweek.
Saint Domingo
Player Valuation: £90m
Same mentality gap as the rest. Good keeper but can't do it in big games, therefore not a good keeper.
He also directly cost us 2 goals so i'll hold the praise thanks
Not sure I agree, Mikey. Think the saves he made were fairly routine that i'd expect any prem keeper to make. The two mistakes are unforgivable though and ultimately decided the outcome.
Did he roll the ball to a white shirt - no snide should have passed it back or bottled it out for a throw in and rollecked him the snide Williams attempt to pass it to one another was pathetic!
RFUS
Anustart
He's saved about 90% of the one on ones he's faced which is mental. Sure, he looked poor for the 2nd but then when most of the time he's got those decisions come out and close the angle spot on, it's easier to forgive him. Thought he wasn't great for their first either but the defending was poor.
It is always a bit harsh to single out players when it's a shocking team performance. Almost everyone was abysmal. Morgan wasn't great but I don't suddenly think he's crap. But singling out Joel, who kept the scoreline down massively today with some great saves, seems harsh.
But that's Everton fans. They love their scapegoats and they'll hide when said scapegoats are playing well and crawl out of the woodwork when they do anything sub par.
It is always a bit harsh to single out players when it's a shocking team performance. Almost everyone was abysmal. Morgan wasn't great but I don't suddenly think he's crap. But singling out Joel, who kept the scoreline down massively today with some great saves, seems harsh.
But that's Everton fans. They love their scapegoats and they'll hide when said scapegoats are playing well and crawl out of the woodwork when they do anything sub par.
- Status
Welcome
Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.
Shop
