Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

Lukaku

Status
Not open for further replies.
The only reason he gets stick is that he seems to lack fundamental footballing skills. I find his goal record baffling when I see him play sometimes but, personally, I don't give a crap what his first touch is like or what he says to the media as long as he sticks it in the back of the net for us.

It's exactly this. When he went through a dry patch recently, he was such a liability that even Arouna Kone felt like a massive upgrade when he was on the pitch, as when Lukaku isn't scoring we may as well be playing with ten men.

If you use Lukaku as a focal point striker and put five chances on a plate for him a game, he'll convert more of them than your average striker will. But that really isn't enough for a top tier team that relies on a cohesive team unit to play at our best. Lukaku is often the weakest link in our side, more often than he is the strongest link when he's scoring.
 
You wouldn't care if in the Euopa League final we are 1-0 up from a Lukaku goal, but then he comes deep to get the ball and his control is so awful he passes it straight to an opposition player who runs through and gets the equaliser (ala Ings at Burnley), we then go on to lose the match.

You wouldn't care cause he'd already scored?

Thats pretty strange if you ask me.


Your completely hypothetical situation has changed my mind. Lukaku OUT.
 
Yeah I remember when Jeffers was 20 and had a near 1 in 2 record overall at Everton and everyone was raving about him based on goals alone. Nobody could question his talent and potential then as well.

Except you could, as his overall game was nowhere near up to scratch and his career showed as such.

Lukaku scores goals, albeit the current love-in is due to 3 goals in 1 game against a sub-par side on the night where he was given all three on a plate - he played very well, but it doesn't excuse the fact that for a good four months now at the very least he's been absolutely dire except for the odd goal going in off his hip or whatever.

I don't dislike Lukaku, I want to like him, but I can't just ignore everything wrong with his game, especially given his last good performance for us was in Europe and he promptly followed that up with months upon months of pure gash, culminating in coming out to the media and claiming he was a big fish in a small pond, despite not being one of our best five players this year.

Let's see him do the business for a good few months before we start labelling him as anything. All he's proven thus far is that he's a good mid-tier Premier League striker who'll get goals like Yakubu did but offer nothing much else on the pitch. For £28m, he needs to be more than the next Yakubu for us over a long period of time.

Well I see you're point about nobody being above criticism. Bit harsh to say all three were on a plate on Thursday mate. He's also been decent for the past few games, definately upped his game.

Difficult to play well when you're feeding off scraps though.
 
Yeah I remember when Jeffers was 20 and had a near 1 in 2 record overall at Everton and everyone was raving about him based on goals alone. Nobody could question his talent and potential then as well.

Except you could, as his overall game was nowhere near up to scratch and his career showed as such.

Lukaku scores goals, albeit the current love-in is due to 3 goals in 1 game against a sub-par side on the night where he was given all three on a plate - he played very well, but it doesn't excuse the fact that for a good four months now at the very least he's been absolutely dire except for the odd goal going in off his hip or whatever.

I don't dislike Lukaku, I want to like him, but I can't just ignore everything wrong with his game, especially given his last good performance for us was in Europe and he promptly followed that up with months upon months of pure gash, culminating in coming out to the media and claiming he was a big fish in a small pond, despite not being one of our best five players this year.

Let's see him do the business for a good few months before we start labelling him as anything. All he's proven thus far is that he's a good mid-tier Premier League striker who'll get goals like Yakubu did but offer nothing much else on the pitch. For £28m, he needs to be more than the next Yakubu for us over a long period of time.
Didn't he miss like 2-3 shots from 5 feet out later on in the game, when they were actually handed on a plate?
 

Also, whoever made the poiint of Jeffers. So one player who didn't live up to potential means another won't?

Also whilst his 1 in 3 goal record was decent, he wasn't banging them in for other clubs before Everton was he? Rom is much more proven at the age he is than Jeffers was.
 
Also, whoever made the poiint of Jeffers. So one player who didn't live up to potential means another won't?

Also whilst his 1 in 3 goal record was decent, he wasn't banging them in for other clubs before Everton was he? Rom is much more proven at the age he is than Jeffers was.

No, I was responding to someone saying Lukaku's talent and potential cannot be questioned - it can, and indeed should be questioned, as he has very obvious weak points to his play.
 

It's exactly this. When he went through a dry patch recently, he was such a liability that even Arouna Kone felt like a massive upgrade when he was on the pitch, as when Lukaku isn't scoring we may as well be playing with ten men.

If you use Lukaku as a focal point striker and put five chances on a plate for him a game, he'll convert more of them than your average striker will. But that really isn't enough for a top tier team that relies on a cohesive team unit to play at our best. Lukaku is often the weakest link in our side, more often than he is the strongest link when he's scoring.


Personally, I don't think we've given him much of a chance in a cohesive team this season. He clearly operates better in a system with two wingers and a firing-on-all-cylinders Barkley, but Martinez has persisted with some very shapeless formations that would limit the service to any striker. I do think bringing on Kone to close out a game after 60 or 70 minutes is the way to go, as his touch and hold-up play is infinitely better.
 
@Tubey defended Jelavic to the hilt when he was falling over like a drunk baby horse and not scoring, but is now giving Lukaku grief.

I can only assume it's racism.

One cost £5m, the other £28m. Both came in on fire, both tailed off dramatically, both have the same style of play.

The price tag matters. Until Lukaku is five times better than Jelavic, he's open to critique.

Records this season:

Lukaku - 7 goals in 25 league games.
Jelavic - 7 goals in 19 league games.

The lad has a lot to prove.
 
One cost £5m, the other £28m. Both came in on fire, both tailed off dramatically, both have the same style of play.

The price tag matters. Until Lukaku is five times better than Jelavic, he's open to critique.

Records this season:

Lukaku - 7 goals in 25 league games.
Jelavic - 7 goals in 19 league games.

The lad has a lot to prove.


One is 21 years old.
 
@Tubey defended Jelavic to the hilt when he was falling over like a drunk baby horse and not scoring, but is now giving Lukaku grief.

I can only assume it's racism.

S3uloHY.gif
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome to GrandOldTeam

Get involved. Registration is simple and free.

Back
Top