Mike Walker V Roberto Martinez

[ianefc]

Yes.

I didn't think we did. But I trust you.

 

[chrissyjack]

Can I vote for Walter Smith ?

 

[hktoffee]

Martinez was a joke. Talked utter crap too. It was all other people's fault but not him lollol. Still remembered 4 wins at Goodison for one full season.

Most importantly, it took £10m to sack him. Worse for pounds in relative terms.

 

[Moomin]

Think a lot of youngsters are voting Martinez as they don't remember the Walker era.

It was grim, very grim.

 

[Minimeister]

Walker was a joke who was found out pretty quickly. With Martinez it took a hell of a lot longer.

 

[Ashtonian]

Martinez for me.

Walker was a crap manager for us sure. our worst ever you could say.

But martinez failed at the basics. so no matter how good elements were it was the basics which relegated one team and nearly destroyed us. and he done it with money to spend. walker didn't have the same resources.

 

[Seathestars]

The question was who was worse, therefore I agree with you, although I suspect you don't.

Now that's confused me.

Martinez, I've never seen anyone so in denial of the obvious.

 

[ianefc]

Think a lot of youngsters are voting Martinez as they don't remember the Walker era.

It was grim, very grim.

You're right, the thread was a mickey take. Martinez was the better Everton manager. IMHO. Just

 

[Groucho]

Martinez by an absolute mile. Walker didn't have anywhere near the squad Martinez had - comparing them is ridiculous.

Both were terrible, but Martinez in his last two seasons was a special type of terrible.

I reckon so. Having seen both and had time to digest, Martinez was the worse manager.

But that's like saying scabies is better than infective acne.

Both awful.

 

[silent bob]

Martinez had some bad luck

He is possibly the luckiest man alive to get the job in the first place and then walking away with an enormous pay off for being utter toilet.

 

[roydo]

Think a lot of youngsters are voting Martinez as they don't remember the Walker era.

It was grim, very grim.

Aye, grimmest of the grim.

Vividly remember being at Wembley, watching a mate play in the FA Vase final, and keeping up to date on a trany radio with THAT match. 0 2, really thought that was it.

Then when the winner went in, jumped up and shouted, during a really boring bit of the Vase game.

 

[MikeH72]

The fact this poll even exists says all you need to know about how highly regarded Martinez is by the fans. Let alone how close it actually is. Brilliant isn't it.

 

[DualityNSNO]

Shockingly close imo.

 

[summerisle]

Did Walker have any redeeming features? Like a really really exciting season before falling apart at the seams?

Thought not.

He played for Watford when they knocked the RS out of the FA Cup.

 

[ianefc]

lollol

At Martinez 'winning' the vote.

So far.