Mikel Arteta [Manager]

[TheBigIguana]

I'm not a big fan of any manager coming in with no real experience as the head man. I'm even less interested in having someone who has worked under someone has good as Pep. How do we know that he's actually good and not that everything is just Pep being amazing? I don't think you can be sure which makes it a big risk.

 

[Rooney_Tunes]

I'm not a big fan of any manager coming in with no real experience as the head man. I'm even less interested in having someone who has worked under someone has good as Pep. How do we know that he's actually good and not that everything is just Pep being amazing? I don't think you can be sure which makes it a big risk.

Everything is a risk; Liverpool took a risk with Klopp, with Van Dyk.

 

[davek]

Everything is a risk; Liverpool took a risk with Klopp, with Van Dyk.

You're comparing a two-time Bundesliga winner and CL final manager with a cone layer who has a competitive managerial record of: managed one senior game and lost it.

The risk in hiring Klopp was minute compared to hiring a no mark like Arteta.

In any case, we have a manager and he will remain in position.

 

[Baines' left foot]

But he wasn’t very nice to us in that one game when Baines shouted at him.

 

[brian labone]

All the people on here saying Arteta has no experience and therefore don't want him, please let us know who you do want and see if we can get him. Maybe we could get experience such as Allardyce, Koeman, Martina, Moyes, plenty of experience there and look where that got us. Give him a chance I believe he will prove better than all the above.

 

[Lelouch]

All the people on here saying Arteta has no experience and therefore don't want him, please let us know who you do want and see if we can get him. Maybe we could get experience such as Allardyce, Koeman, Martina, Moyes, plenty of experience there and look where that got us. Give him a chance I believe he will prove better than all the above.

So you name what people would label bad managers/players who have experience and use that as your argument in why we shouldn't give Arteta a man who hasn't registered a single minute in managing a team in a football match a chance as our manager.
okay m8.

 

[matty1878]

All the people on here saying Arteta has no experience and therefore don't want him, please let us know who you do want and see if we can get him. Maybe we could get experience such as Allardyce, Koeman, Martina, Moyes, plenty of experience there and look where that got us. Give him a chance I believe he will prove better than all the above.

We can’t have someone with no experience it’s pretty simple

 

[brian labone]

So you name what people would label bad managers/players who have experience and use that as your argument in why we shouldn't give Arteta a man who hasn't registered a single minute in managing a team in a football match a chance as our manager.
okay m8.

I could name a lot more managers than the few I have already mentioned that brought us nothing and I noticed you never came up with a single manager we could get. For goodness sake we have won nothing for the life time of some of our young fans, for once try something different, I am only saying this in case Silva is sacked.

 

[brian labone]

We can’t have someone with no experience it’s pretty simple

We can’t have someone with no experience it’s pretty simple

Why not as I explained experience is not everything, everybody has to start somewhere, and nobody offers any so called better candidates.

 

[Lelouch]

I could name a lot more managers than the few I have already mentioned that brought us nothing and I noticed you never came up with a single manager we could get. For goodness sake we have won nothing for the life time of some of our young fans, for once try something different, I am only saying this in case Silva is sacked.

Yeah I'm one of them and Arteta is an awful shout for me, He could be really good but we'll never know because he hasn't managed at all and you want his first job to be Everton who are trying everything to try and get top 6 and people think Arteta out of every managerial candidate is the answer? No way.

 

[buededw1]

Always a risk with appointing a new manager, but history has shown that it does work.

The fact he is leader (captain Barcelona B, Spain u21, Everton & Arsenal) and is learning from one of the best managers in the world has to negate some of that risk. He is also multilingual and in a team full of various nationalities, i'm sure this would make a difference.

If we was ever to take a risk he is without doubt the man I would like to take a risk on.

Wouldn't surprise me if his best mate Tim Cahill ended up joining his staff, I would love that!

 

[Cels]

Has Mikel Arteta indicated in any way that he would be interested in being the next Everton manager? There appears to be the assumption that we just have to tell Arteta we're interested in appointing him and he'll drop everything and coming riding into Goodison Park to save the day. Mikel Arteta is well respected in football and his stock is reasonably high; that could easily be wiped out within one season of being the Everton manager. He's not daft and knows that the Everton job would be a massive gamble and could set him right back in his aspirations to become a top-class manager... if that's what he wants to be, of course.

 

[BirkenheadBlue]

Yes it could. Very easily. Remeber when we sacked Koeman? Everyone agreed he deserved the sack, and he did, but things got far worse very quickly after he left under Rhino so much so that we had to reach out to BFS to bail us out.

Tell you what, I knew Allardyce was doing a good job of rewriting history with the media, didn't realise he had been so effective at it with our own fans.

We were 18th when Koeman got sacked, 13th when Allardyce took over.

The board pushed the "Allardyce panic button" far too early.

 

[Rooney_Tunes]

Has Mikel Arteta indicated in any way that he would be interested in being the next Everton manager? There appears to be the assumption that we just have to tell Arteta we're interested in appointing him and he'll drop everything and coming riding into Goodison Park to save the day. Mikel Arteta is well respected in football and his stock is reasonably high; that could easily be wiped out within one season of being the Everton manager. He's not daft and knows that the Everton job would be a massive gamble and could set him right back in his aspirations to become a top-class manager... if that's what he wants to be, of course.

Or it could fasttrack him to stardom!

 

[Dymak]

Rafael Benitez plays 8-1-1 formations and is currently being outperformed by a Steve Bruce led Newcastle. Ronald Koeman was supposed to be the well experienced disciplinarian with no previous connection to the club that people are saying that we need right now, and he was nothing but a meat headed joke.

Silva’s premier league ‘experience’ consisted of relegating Hull and being sacked from Watford as he was proceeding over a doomed period of relegation form that has become customary during his time at Everton.

I don’t see how Arteta could do worse than Koeman the meat head and Silva the relegation specialist. In all likelihood he’d have us finishing in 8th like every other manager that we employ.

I’d have him at Everton, not because I think he can’t do any worse than all the other jokers but because I think he has the potential to do a lot better.