Morgan Schneiderlin

davek · January 28, 2017

Moomin said:
Come on now, he is a new player so everyone is going to pretend they watched his games for Southampton and United and kept a diary of the things he done.

He will be automatically brilliant without kicking a ball for us.

Youtube analysts. They know everything.

davek · January 28, 2017

wainy said:
Who would you have signed instead mate? Modric? Iniesta?

Your dour outlook on everything, literally everything Everton, is just depressing.

I'd have signed one other than Sigurdsson.

Nymzee · January 28, 2017

davek said:
In a nutshell: no one knows what his game is really like.

Well we do, he's been in the Prem for years. Not like we picked him up from the Qatari league is it.

bol-uk · January 28, 2017

davek said:
You think you know how Schneiderlin plays, but you dont. You dont know a payers strengths and weaknesses until they are in your team and then you sit up and pay attention. When a player is at another club (unless they are a megastar that you cant help notice their game because they are on the telly so much and their game is analysed so much) you just dont appreciate their full game.

How that ^^^ is controversial I dont know. It is a common sense statement.

http://www.fourfourtwo.com/features/stats-zone-premier-league-central-midfielder-year

http://metro.co.uk/2015/10/19/manch...er-in-morgan-schneiderlin-stats-show-5448051/

http://www.manchestereveningnews.co...nchester-united-stats-suggest-morgan-10662330

http://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/row-zed/manchester-united-new-boy-morgan-6064524

davek · January 28, 2017

ijjysmith said:
Why do you keep trying to tell us then?

I'm telling you nothing about his game; I'm stating the position was well catered to..

Moomin · January 28, 2017

davek said:
Youtube analysts. They know everything.

They've also signed him on FIFA.

wainy · January 28, 2017

davek said:
You think you know how Schneiderlin plays, but you dont. You dont know a payers strengths and weaknesses until they are in your team and then you sit up and pay attention. When a player is at another club (unless they are a megastar that you cant help notice their game because they are on the telly so much and their game is analysed so much) you just dont appreciate their full game.

How that ^^^ is controversial I dont know. It is a common sense statement.

Mate just stop. He's a proven French international. Fairly certain RK knows his game inside out from his time at Soton.

Imo a midfield of :-

Davies Gana schneiderlin
Barkley

Will do very well, I don't see what you are concerned about.

Nymzee · January 28, 2017

Moomin said:
They've also signed him on FIFA.

We don't need to; he's already at Everton on FIFA.

davek · January 28, 2017

bol-uk said:
so?

Gueye scored no goals in 35 for Villa. Your points are void always, you just say anything to get a wind up.

Well done.

My point was you posted what you believed were great stats about him at S'ton; well his stats at United were less so...so, as stated, neither you nor anyone else know wtf we're getting here.

wainy · January 28, 2017

davek said:
I'd have signed one other than Sigurdsson.

Would he have kicked us on? Debatable. Flopped at spurs and shining in a team of utter crabs at Swansea.

ijjysmith · January 28, 2017

davek said:
I'm telling you nothing about his game; I'm stating the position was well catered to..

Fair answer using your opinion.

You realise some, including me, have actually seen him play quite a bit. In person though yeah?

Remember when I hated the idea of us signing James McCarthy back in the day? But once he'd signed I tried to look at the positives and got right behind him? Maybe you could try the same? Just maybe. And please?

davek · January 28, 2017

Nymzee said:
Well we do, he's been in the Prem for years. Not like we picked him up from the Qatari league is it.

Yes, but you dont drill down to the nth degree on a player at another club like you do on one at your own.

davek · January 28, 2017

wainy said:
Mate just stop. He's a proven French international. Fairly certain RK knows his game inside out from his time at Soton.

Imo a midfield of :-

Davies Gana schneiderlin
Barkley

Will do very well, I don't see what you are concerned about.

Yes, Koeman does. But you know a surface reality of how he plays, nothing any deeper than that. Its just a selective comparison of opta stats and video packages. Nonsense stuff.

The Rhino · January 28, 2017

ijjysmith said:
Fair answer using your opinion.

You realise some, including me, have actually seen him play quite a bit. In person though yeah?

Remember when I hated the idea of us signing James McCarthy back in the day? But once he'd signed I tried to look at the positives and got right behind him? Maybe you could try the same? Just maybe. And please?

Dont bother man he's become a joke on the forum. Don't know if he's missus has packed him in or something.

I'm glad we have options in midfield. Barry will be gone next season/one foot in the coaching door and Besic has never been consistent/impressed me. You would expect Mccarthy out the door aswell for regular football.

We have the best CDM stats wise in the league In Gueye, Schneiderlein who if he can recapture his saints form was one of the best CDM'S in the league and a big prospect in Davies. For once injury won't cripple us in the centre.