Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

Moyes Potential Replacement

Who do you want? - being realistic

  • Roberto Martinez

    Votes: 221 13.8%
  • Vitor Pereira

    Votes: 594 37.2%
  • Neil Lennon

    Votes: 40 2.5%
  • Di Matteo

    Votes: 58 3.6%
  • Slaven Bilic

    Votes: 73 4.6%
  • Michael Laudrup

    Votes: 410 25.7%
  • Malky Mackay

    Votes: 33 2.1%
  • From within the club

    Votes: 60 3.8%
  • Other

    Votes: 108 6.8%

  • Total voters
    1,597
Status
Not open for further replies.
I was vehemently and hugely against him based on what I saw as his under performance at wigan. Even after they thrashed us, I blamed that more on us than them.

Then I looked into the finances to do a thread about wigan and I appreciated a bit better how difficult his situation was. So I started to come around a little as to him as a fallback option if we couldn't get someone I actually wanted.

But then he took a team out in a big game against a vastly superior team for the biggest stakes and they were cool, calm, classy and worthy winners.

And that's won me over, entirely. I still think we'd finish bottom half under martinez but if he can produce another cup run like that and keep us playing easy on the eye football, I'd take it.

His cup record before this season was dire. Get ready for weakened teams in cup games a la moyes.
 
Or in other words, Roberto Martinez' Wigan beat both Everton and Manchester City on their way to lifting the 2013 FA Cup.

Man United fans are gibing it the whole "Moyes has never won anything" but those who know football refer to the constraints he worked under at Everton. The same applies to Martinez and Wigan, they are the smallest club in the premier league with small attendances and a tiny turnover!

The only smaller club to have ever played in the Premier League was probably Swindon Town.
And over 36 games only 2 teams are worse than Wigan.
 
His cup record before this season was dire. Get ready for weakened teams in cup games a la moyes.

I know it was, it was one of the reasons I was so against him. But it took him less time in the PL than moyes to reach his first quarter final, his first semi final and his first final.

If he's got to grip with the cups now, it'll be good for us.
 
http://www.grandoldteam.com/news/fans-view/2013/may/11/no-excuses-kenwright-get-the-right-man


There´s a myriad of reasons why Everton miss out on the odd player or nine. As a fanbase, we expect that we won´t be signing Messi anytime soon.

However, there´s absolutely no reason - financially, or due to club reputation - why Bill Kenwright should not look far and wide and bring the right man in at Everton, no matter what.

When Moyes announced his intention to leave Everton, it was met with a mixture of surprise, disappointment and acceptance by a lot of supporters. For me, the bigger surprise and cause of more disappointment was the immediate betting list for next Everton manager.

Malky Mackay, Neil Lennon, Roberto Martinez... even Phil Neville, all leading contenders.

Nothing against Mackay and Martinez really (I actually like both managers), but it was maddening to see the bookies automatically look down the leagues to inferior teams rather than consider the continent and beyond for managers who are looking to test their mettle in the Premier League.

That said, I can hardly blame the media. Everton have been painted as plucky underdogs for well over a decade, so to see the clowns at TalkSport stupidly mention Tony Pulis as a good candidate for the Everton job is hardly surprising. But my biggest fear is that, as a fanbase, we buy into the usual media crusade painting us as a slightly older version of Wigan rather than the top club that we are.

That isn´t delusion by the way. We´re a top six club in the most popular league in the world. Our outgoing manager is one of the highest paid managers in world football. We have just proven that doing a good job at Goodison Park can lead to the very top roles in world football, both as players (see Arteta, Gravesen, Rooney etc.) and managers.

So whilst in 2002 we were in dire straits and looking down the leagues for an up and comer to take a chance on was acceptable, in 2013 it´s a whole new kettle of fish.

This summer, we will have the increased TV money to spend, plus a likely big money sale of Fellaini and/or Baines, along with Heitinga and Mucha, Neville retiring etc.

That´s a lot of the wage bill freed up and a lot of capital to give the new manager to stamp his authority on the team and start anew.

Therefore, there is no excuse at all - not one - for not looking far and wide to bring the best man in for the job. Not the guy happiest to take a low wage just to have the marquee job. Not the man who´ll happily tow the line and big up his "great relationship" with the chairman, like they´re best buds. Not the guy who shows the most enthusiasm for Coronation Street in the interview.

No, the best man for Everton, no matter what the cost. It´s going to be a revolutionary summer at Goodison Park - this needs to be right. Get it right Bill.
 
The whole Wigan team , worth a massive 11 million pounds (worth less than Fellaini ) outplayed the small Man City team worth 240 million pounds -
how will the Moyes supporter club explain that mismatch ?
and by the way Wigan wiped the floor with Everton on their way to the FA Cup as well -
must be something in the Wigan water I suppose - Martinez is just a name
 

http://www.grandoldteam.com/news/fans-view/2013/may/11/no-excuses-kenwright-get-the-right-man


There´s a myriad of reasons why Everton miss out on the odd player or nine. As a fanbase, we expect that we won´t be signing Messi anytime soon.

However, there´s absolutely no reason - financially, or due to club reputation - why Bill Kenwright should not look far and wide and bring the right man in at Everton, no matter what.

When Moyes announced his intention to leave Everton, it was met with a mixture of surprise, disappointment and acceptance by a lot of supporters. For me, the bigger surprise and cause of more disappointment was the immediate betting list for next Everton manager.

Malky Mackay, Neil Lennon, Roberto Martinez... even Phil Neville, all leading contenders.

Nothing against Mackay and Martinez really (I actually like both managers), but it was maddening to see the bookies automatically look down the leagues to inferior teams rather than consider the continent and beyond for managers who are looking to test their mettle in the Premier League.

That said, I can hardly blame the media. Everton have been painted as plucky underdogs for well over a decade, so to see the clowns at TalkSport stupidly mention Tony Pulis as a good candidate for the Everton job is hardly surprising. But my biggest fear is that, as a fanbase, we buy into the usual media crusade painting us as a slightly older version of Wigan rather than the top club that we are.

That isn´t delusion by the way. We´re a top six club in the most popular league in the world. Our outgoing manager is one of the highest paid managers in world football. We have just proven that doing a good job at Goodison Park can lead to the very top roles in world football, both as players (see Arteta, Gravesen, Rooney etc.) and managers.

So whilst in 2002 we were in dire straits and looking down the leagues for an up and comer to take a chance on was acceptable, in 2013 it´s a whole new kettle of fish.

This summer, we will have the increased TV money to spend, plus a likely big money sale of Fellaini and/or Baines, along with Heitinga and Mucha, Neville retiring etc.

That´s a lot of the wage bill freed up and a lot of capital to give the new manager to stamp his authority on the team and start anew.

Therefore, there is no excuse at all - not one - for not looking far and wide to bring the best man in for the job. Not the guy happiest to take a low wage just to have the marquee job. Not the man who´ll happily tow the line and big up his "great relationship" with the chairman, like they´re best buds. Not the guy who shows the most enthusiasm for Coronation Street in the interview.

No, the best man for Everton, no matter what the cost. It´s going to be a revolutionary summer at Goodison Park - this needs to be right. Get it right Bill.

Where getting Neville lad

Deal with it now to ease the pain
 
I know we all have preferences, gut feelings.

My preference is Pelligrini.

My gut feeling is David Weir.
 
I was vehemently and hugely against him based on what I saw as his under performance at wigan. Even after they thrashed us, I blamed that more on us than them.

Then I looked into the finances to do a thread about wigan and I appreciated a bit better how difficult his situation was. So I started to come around a little as to him as a fallback option if we couldn't get someone I actually wanted.

But then he took a team out in a big game against a vastly superior team for the biggest stakes and they were cool, calm, classy and worthy winners.

And that's won me over, entirely. I still think we'd finish bottom half under martinez but if he can produce another cup run like that and keep us playing easy on the eye football, I'd take it.
Ok thanks for the response mate.
 

The whole Wigan team , worth a massive 11 million pounds (worth less than Fellaini ) outplayed the small Man City team worth 240 million pounds -
how will the Moyes supporter club explain that mismatch ?
and by the way Wigan wiped the floor with Everton on their way to the FA Cup as well -
must be something in the Wigan water I suppose - Martinez is just a name

This is just a one off match 50/50 chance unlike the league games you play 38 matches. Can you explain why they will relegate then?
 
And that's won me over, entirely. I still think we'd finish bottom half under martinez but if he can produce another cup run like that and keep us playing easy on the eye football, I'd take it.

Popcorn. Piles of the stuff, fifty feet high, for as far as the eye can see in any direction.

IF he can produce another cup run? And what possible guarantee can their be of that? Your opponents in a cup run are determined by blind luck. On the other hand, your opponents in the league are certain, therefore your performance in the league is a better barometer of your true level of ability. Prospective players consider that when deciding whether to join the club, amongst other things.

I appreciate that he'd have a better squad to work with here and, almost unbelievably, more money. But even you're pointing out that he'd likely do worse in the league than Moyes has. The odds of a good cup run are reliant in large part on the draw. And that's not a good enough reason to pay more for Martinez than you would have to for Pereira or Girard.
 
http://www.grandoldteam.com/news/fans-view/2013/may/11/no-excuses-kenwright-get-the-right-man


There´s a myriad of reasons why Everton miss out on the odd player or nine. As a fanbase, we expect that we won´t be signing Messi anytime soon.

However, there´s absolutely no reason - financially, or due to club reputation - why Bill Kenwright should not look far and wide and bring the right man in at Everton, no matter what.

When Moyes announced his intention to leave Everton, it was met with a mixture of surprise, disappointment and acceptance by a lot of supporters. For me, the bigger surprise and cause of more disappointment was the immediate betting list for next Everton manager.

Malky Mackay, Neil Lennon, Roberto Martinez... even Phil Neville, all leading contenders.

Nothing against Mackay and Martinez really (I actually like both managers), but it was maddening to see the bookies automatically look down the leagues to inferior teams rather than consider the continent and beyond for managers who are looking to test their mettle in the Premier League.

That said, I can hardly blame the media. Everton have been painted as plucky underdogs for well over a decade, so to see the clowns at TalkSport stupidly mention Tony Pulis as a good candidate for the Everton job is hardly surprising. But my biggest fear is that, as a fanbase, we buy into the usual media crusade painting us as a slightly older version of Wigan rather than the top club that we are.

That isn´t delusion by the way. We´re a top six club in the most popular league in the world. Our outgoing manager is one of the highest paid managers in world football. We have just proven that doing a good job at Goodison Park can lead to the very top roles in world football, both as players (see Arteta, Gravesen, Rooney etc.) and managers.

So whilst in 2002 we were in dire straits and looking down the leagues for an up and comer to take a chance on was acceptable, in 2013 it´s a whole new kettle of fish.

This summer, we will have the increased TV money to spend, plus a likely big money sale of Fellaini and/or Baines, along with Heitinga and Mucha, Neville retiring etc.

That´s a lot of the wage bill freed up and a lot of capital to give the new manager to stamp his authority on the team and start anew.

Therefore, there is no excuse at all - not one - for not looking far and wide to bring the best man in for the job. Not the guy happiest to take a low wage just to have the marquee job. Not the man who´ll happily tow the line and big up his "great relationship" with the chairman, like they´re best buds. Not the guy who shows the most enthusiasm for Coronation Street in the interview.

No, the best man for Everton, no matter what the cost. It´s going to be a revolutionary summer at Goodison Park - this needs to be right. Get it right Bill.
This ^^^ for me.
 
Very much like Moyes at United, whoever the new man is, the biggest thing he will require is patience.

I get the feeling that both jobs could almost mirror each other next season, as both managers try to put their stamp on their respective new clubs. Whoever comes in for us is obviously going to have to oversee a fairly big change at the club.

They will have the arduous task of replacing one or two key players who seem to be on their way out (Fellaini / Rooney) reducing the overall age of the squad as well as implementing their own ideas and style into the Football club.

It would be incredible if both teams maintained the level that they performed at this season in the wake of such change, but as we saw at the beginning of both the Moyes and Ferguson eras, it could take some time before the new man gets the team showing the kind of improvement we are all anticipating.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome to GrandOldTeam

Get involved. Registration is simple and free.

Back
Top