If they wanted simple they could'e done something like this. Doesn't need to look like a cartoon, which is apparently how modern design has to look... -.-
If we have to dispense with the crest we've used for the last ten years (and I don't accept that this is the case) then I'd take this over the travesty put forward by the club every single time. Every single time.
It highlights an important factor - the new rendering of Prince Rupert's tower looks abysmal. The existing version has been used since forever and should not be altered.