It's not one thing or the other though. Transfer record or not he spent a fortune at the time for Chelsea and was bankrolled again at Madrid. He clearly maximised potential at Porto but they weren't exactly in our current position.
When faced with the challenge of overhauling Barca and with all the money in the world available to him he proved himself a one trick pony. And again this season at Chelsea he organised them to take a poor league last season but at the expense of even medium term progress.
He's always ready to move on because he knows his style isn't sustainable.
I have absolutely no doubt his game management skills are right up there but at this club I don't see them being that much more successful than Moyes.
We can improve this side of things without a manager that abandons all the stability this club has.
Alex Ferguson spent big at United mate - and consistantly did so
Much of our own clubs success was built upon spending big and outpaying what our rivals did - we didn't get the mersey millionaires nickname for nothing.
Our current manager has paid out 3 of the 4 highest ever transfer fees paid by the club, and bought one player for double the transfer record for fees paid by us
Show me a manager who has managed Madrid or Chelsea and who hasn't spent a huge amount of money?
You make it sound like overhauling Barca is a simple task - your going to discount anyone who managed Madrid and lost out on titles to Barca then you are scratching off some very very good managers who failed, Anchelotti and Pelligrini being just two of them - also as Perez basically buys whatever players he wants at madrid and demands the manager makes them into a team - then i won't hold only winning the league 1 in 3 seasons their against him really...
As for Inter and Porto - don't think he actually spent a huge amount at either club and won the CL with both
You say stability mate - don't you mean stagnation, how exactly is this club prior to the takeover in any way shape or form a stable club - taking out loans to be able to operate, having to sell players to pay the banks, the very definition of a stability i wouldnt ever wish to see again.
As for Mourinho not doing any better than Myes would, it's a plainly ridisculous thing to say mate, one has won everywhere he has ever been including against all the odds with Porto and Inter, and one has never ever been a winner in any job he has ever had.
Chelsea this season became fractured and Hazzard - the player of the season in the league last year decided he couldnt be arsed - for either mourinho or hiddink - that alone would have wrecked any teams season mate
I understand that a lot of our supporters almost seem happy with our role in the grand scheme of the premier league circus, never challenging, never in danger, making up the numbers, but never getting our hopes up - so they can't be too dissapointed when we fall.
Honestly think if given the choice of doing what liverpool did in 13/14 or what we did, some of out fans would have chosen ourt season compared to theirs as we'd have seen the negatives not the positives of the ride.