Fair enough Benitez has won nothing.. but neither did Moyes.. you mention the league positions.. on paper they look pretty decent enough but when you look a little deeper the club was as far away from top four as you could get because Moyes never dented or even threatened to break up the top four of United.. Arsenal.. Chelsea or Liverpool on any sort of regular basis..We finished 5th twice under him as well, 6th, 7th 4 times. So he did come close.
Purple patch over a season and a half? He saved them from relegation before being let go, then was brought back in to save them again before the following season getting 6th, where they are now. Hardly a purple patch. A purple patch would be being unbeaten in like 5 games, and then winning 1 from 11 following that. Benitez was the definition of purple patch this season.
It's not an opinion either, in the last 2 decades, has moyes been our best manager? Only one to get us to finals, regularly had us in Europe and our highest finish. Please show me which manager has done better for us in that time.
You don't support us, so stop trying to tell our fans how to think or feel. It's egotistical of you to think you have that right or that you know better when you don't know anything about us other than what you quickly Google or you have learnt from having supported Liverpool your entire life.
If benitez does win a trophy, then yes he would be deemed more successful. If that is while we are flirting with relegation, then maybe not. He hasn't earnt the same respect Moyes had with us. And only a kopite would suggest that he has. Because so far, benitez has won nothing with us. Hell, he has barely won a game with us.
Look if you want to appoint Moyes or think he has better standing in the game than Benitez it’s up to you... as for me making comments or observations I am entitled to that just as much as you so get used to that my friend.. you are not anymore special than anybody else that posts..it’s a forum and that’s what it’s for.. people to agree and disagree on the Club in question..