He was my pick because I thought we could use a huge dose of pragmatism to sort out the defence and someone who could get rid of players who disgracefully downed tools and tanked games for this club...something they should have been placed on the transfer list for.
The reality however has been that no such pragmatism has arrived with him. He hasn't adapted the players he has here and he's forever bleating about buying a new team. The defence is stil hopeless and vulnerable and the standard of football (shockingly because I never expected anything of the sort) is ale house class. He's also rewarded players who last season stabbed us in the back and has pacified them with a lot of game time - possibly in an effort to get them onside. Baines for one should be nowhere near this football club, never mind a first team starting place.
Is it a mistake to have wanted him? Yes. I think this is as good as it's ever going to get with Koeman. Regardless of spending more cash the method is there and won't change and it won't ever elevate us into contenders. I truly wish we'd made Fabien Favre our manager. We may have missed out on a manager that could have transformed us.