C'mon, he had to sort that defence out. You can't expect many people to turn you into a great attacking force AND guarantee survival in that short time frame. Everton were shipping a ridiculous amount of goals before he arrived, in Europe and domestically with some shocking results. And yeah, Everton won 3-0 or something against West Ham the day or day after he was appointed, but his appointment did seem to give everyone a lift. You can choose not to give him credit for that win, that's your right, but I'm not sure if Unsworth could have got that reaction on his own. Their heads looked like they were down before he arrived, you didn't look like a cohesive unit whatsoever, and you were hovering just above the relegation zone. But maybe anyone could have saved Everton, and it wouldn't have mattered if it was Tony Pulis, Mick McCarthy or Joe Kinnear taking over, we don't know, but to me it did look like Everton were in serious trouble before he arrived. But you'd probably know better.
The common wisdom seemed to be that you'd sold your biggest goal threat, not replaced him, and you had a scatter gun approach in the transfer market with some technically good players, but it just wasn't gelling and it could have gone very bad... in the absence of a cohesive unit.
He's done okay, give him that at least!