2024/25 Sean Dyche - Sacked

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well it definitely is because again this season most of our wins will be against the bottom sides.
We may beat a Utd or arsenal,
Chelsea like we do every season.
But under dyche we don’t lay a glove against the top 6/7 sides away from home .

As opposed to all those away wins at those grounds before Dyche (covid season apart)
 


Does this concern you as much as how he waits until players are fully fit before starting them in the PL?

Yet Tarkowski just last week admitted he's been playing with knocks, so not fully fit...

Both Doucoure and McNeil last season were rushed straight back into the first team after injury, Doucoures injury being a pretty serious one too, both looked way off the pace for weeks after.

He admitted he maybe rushed Branthwaite back too soon the other day.

He refuses to sub clearly exhausted players when he has subs on the bench unused. Who knows how much Tims injury came from that ultimately. Garner he deffo rushed back before being fully fit also, hence a few games then breaks down again for a durable player, same goes for Mykolenko, injured rushed back injured again rinse repeat.

The only single player you can use to show Dyche being cautious bringing players m back really is DCL
 
Apart from Carlo's COVID win at the RS I can't remember when we last beat a top 6 team away from home

Must be West Ham under Carlo in 20/21 if you talk in the moment of playing.

Or of the classical top 6, also Arsenal the same season, but they didn't finish top 6 that season.
 
Yet Tarkowski just last week admitted he's been playing with knocks, so not fully fit...

Both Doucoure and McNeil last season were rushed straight back into the first team after injury, Doucoures injury being a pretty serious one too, both looked way off the pace for weeks after.

He admitted he maybe rushed Branthwaite back too soon the other day.

He refuses to sub clearly exhausted players when he has subs on the bench unused. Who knows how much Tims injury came from that ultimately. Garner he deffo rushed back before being fully fit also, hence a few games then breaks down again for a durable player, same goes for Mykolenko, injured rushed back injured again rinse repeat.

The only single player you can use to show Dyche being cautious bringing players m back really is DCL

Players play all the time with knocks. Very few players are 100% all the time. Listen to some ex players about how often they'd use anti-inflammatory meds and such. There's a difference though between not being 100% and being just not fit enough.

Also, there's a hell of a lot of speculation in your assertions. You have no idea what sort of fitness levels these players have been showing before getting picked, but I'm sure the sports science, physios, manager and player are all included in the decisions regarding fitness. You can't just assume that it's on the manager every time a player suffers a setback.
 
Players play all the time with knocks. Very few players are 100% all the time. Listen to some ex players about how often they'd use anti-inflammatory meds and such. There's a difference though between not being 100% and being just not fit enough.

Also, there's a hell of a lot of speculation in your assertions. You have no idea what sort of fitness levels these players have been showing before getting picked, but I'm sure the sports science, physios, manager and player are all included in the decisions regarding fitness. You can't just assume that it's on the manager every time a player suffers a setback.

Conversely you can't then assume it's all on the manager when a players return to fitness and the team goes well.

He's either responsible or not, way too much trying to give Dyche credit for the positive and shifting it for any negative stuff on here from some.
 

Conversely you can't then assume it's all on the manager when a players return to fitness and the team goes well.

Honestly mate, I have no idea what you're trying to say here. Why would I assume the manager would get all the credit for a player returning to fitness? His job is to get them in the team playing well. If he does that, it's a tick in a box for him.

Players get injured. Some more than others. Some players have spells when they struggle and spells when they're fine. I'm sure the manager might get it wrong from time to time, as he's alluded to with Branthwaite, but it doesn't mean it's his fault every time a player has fitness issues or a setback.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top