Alcaraz would alright, Kone would be good and McGeady would be a bit sh*t. Overall - MEH. The ages are a bit worrying from a financial point of view. What if Kone and McGeady don't work out? No sell-on value. I'm going to say it: I don't think Moyes would have touched any of these three, bar possibly Alcaraz and before people kick off about me bringing Moyes up, his standards have to be kept in the transfer market if we're even to tread water here.
I still think we need a special striker if we're going to get into the top 4 at any point. Even just a Yak of 2008 would be brilliant. A young player like Bony would be fantastic. I don't think Kone will be that, but he will be an improvement. No doubts there.
Unless these cats are coming in to beef the squad up a bit before we bring in a Honda, Bony or some marquee signing of that ilk, I am going to assume this is going to be all we have to spend. In which case, unless Kone starts lashing them in left, right and centre, we can forget about the top 4. Top 6 would be on though, as long as we only sell John.