Im not saying its all Rooney's fault, or that he for sure needs to be dropped, but I think the results are alarming. He was fine in the europa league qualifiers, but lets face it, thats low level competition. Since then, in the league, the league cup, and our one actual Europa League game so far, we have played 720 minutes. Rooney has played 563 of those minutes. In the 563 minutes he has been on the field in meaningful games, we have only scored 2 goals, both his. No other player has scored when Rooney is on the field. None. I dont think that says good things about how he helps the team. We have allowed 11 goals in that same time. When Rooney is on the field we have scored 2, and allowed 11. We average a goal ever 282 minutes, and giving up a goal every 51 minutes.
We have had 157 minutes without Rooney on the field. In that time we have scored 5 goals, and given up 3. All 3 goals given up were in the last 8 minutes of the United game. Without those 8 minutes, its 149 minutes with 0 goals conceded, and 5 goals allowed, or a goal every 31 minutes.
Im not saying the statistics are for sure predicting the future, but the results are kind of striking.
TLDR: 563 minutes of Rooney, 2 goals scored, 11 allowed. 157 minutes without, 5 goals scored, 3 allowed, all 3 in the last 8 minutes of the United game.