I consider winners as 'outstanding servants'. He is not a winner. And he likely never will be. The Everton players who won things with the club must piss themselves to see such accolades placed on him. In fact, it's a symbol of just how far we've been distanced from the top table that statements like yours can be made.
Ray Wilson; Sandy Brown; John Bailey; Pat Van den Hauwe; Paul Power; Gary Ablett.
Names like that are 'outstanding' as left backs.
Baines is a player who, as really an adapted winger, hit on a partnership with a hard working Pienaar and was able for a few seasons to play some memorable matches going forward.
That's it.
I maybe have a more exacting criteria to fill than you for heroes. Your's let's a lot of people in who really aren't up to the mark.