The bending of PSR rules

[wainy]

Ridiculous stuff. In a world where Man Utd pay 80m in good faith for Antony how do you even begin to decide whether a fee agreed between two clubs is good faith or bad faith?

Completely unenforceable if they tried to do anything. The player is worth what the buying team wants to pay. Smell my cheese.

 

[Tony’s Carp]

Not a lot they can do to us, my defense would be, we sold Ellis Simms and Tom Cannon who are similar stature to Dobbin for around a similar price. Do one.

I think the lad going to Chelsea for 19m has raised more eyebrows. I think both us and Villa could justify 9m each for Dobbin and Tim, it’s maybe the top end of fair value but it’s not ridiculous for two decent young players.

 

[Tin-Tin]

How on earth can the PL start deciding how much a youth player is worth?

City paid £45m for Palmer who had played about 3 games. Thats a steal now. Clubs are forking out £5/6m on random 15 and 16 year olds yet absolutely nothing said.

Must be Ratcliffe or Levy kicking off, vultures.

 

[Bedfordblue]

I think for those that don't bother to find out for themselves we should just start making up comedy answers.

Every player we sell before June 30th counts as one extra penalty to the RS next season

That’s probably already in D1ck Masters rules somewhere

 

[bluenorthwarrior]

Ridiculous stuff. In a world where Man Utd pay 80m in good faith for Antony how do you even begin to decide whether a fee agreed between two clubs is good faith or bad faith?

Where the PL acting in good faith when demanding a penalty larger than that for administration for a relatively small first offence?

Or when they then demanded a far lower penalty for a much larger breach by a different club?

Or when brushing Chelsea issues into the long grass. Or accepting selling a hotel to yourself is perfectly proper and all part of a football clubs usual trading?

Good faith my a$$.

 

[Charles Hawtrey]

Setting up a European Super League with a bunch of Euro clubs..... yeah! good faith!

 

[Eidean]

Hahaha they’re a laugh aren’t they, the PL.

Chelsea sell a hotel? Liverpool & City spend years selling youth players for “inflated prices”. Anyone close to PSR?

“MAKE SURE YOU SELL PLAYERS OR WE’LL GIVE A POINTS DEDUCTIONS”

Okay

“NO NOT THOSE ONES”

 

[Blue peter]

Ridiculous stuff. In a world where Man Utd pay 80m in good faith for Antony how do you even begin to decide whether a fee agreed between two clubs is good faith or bad faith?

I think we go a little further to test the boundaries to rile them up and sell Stanley Mills back to ourselves for £30m

 

[phdeasy]

Ridiculous stuff. In a world where Man Utd pay 80m in good faith for Antony how do you even begin to decide whether a fee agreed between two clubs is good faith or bad faith?

The prem didn't seem to care when Saudi came knocking for completely inflated prices

 

[Victus]

Selling Branthwaite for cheaper than we would like to fit PSR is 'acting in good faith' though.

 

[ToffeeTim]

The premier league is a joke competition

 

[ToffeeTim]

Why are the media even promoting this story? Because its not a story.

It was transactions for 9m not 90m. That's a standard transfer fee in this day and age.

 

[Goat]

Why are the media even promoting this story?

Because it creates clicks and outrage.

 

[blaze]

The PL can't do anything outside of changing the rules on how the accountancy side of things is done but that'll never happen because there would be too many clubs who vote against it. Other than clubs admitting this is what they're doing the PL can't prove the value of a player to a club.

 

[Damo_1878]

This is all coming from certain clubs pushing out media narratives - which is them lobbying because the advantage they thought they could yet again take advantage of they can't

They're not happy hence why such a fuss is now being kicked up